Search blog.co.uk

Obesity Epedemic: 'Not individuals fault'

by Oregano @ 2007-10-17 - 11:15:17

Today a report from the Governments Foresight programme warns about the obesity-caused health crisis facing this country. The evidence is quite alarming:

- According to the International Obesity Taskforce, adult obesity (body mass index > 30) in England has increased threefold between 1980 and morbid obesity (BMI>40) increased threefold too.
- Childhood obesity has also increase the Economic and Social Research Council reports that 10% of six-yearolds are now obese.
- Being overweight is responsible for 90% of type 2 diabetes cases
- Being overweight is responsible for 85% of high blood pressure cases
- Obesity doubles the risk of heart attack or stroke.
- Obesity reduces life expectancy by 13 years.

This is alarming especially if the state (NHS) will pick up the tab for treating the problem some decades in the future. Suffering from being overweight is not exactly making life more pleasant (and I say that as somebody who is overweight). The health side effects are quite terrible.

Yet, I cannot understand why so many British journalists report the problem as somehow inevitable and imply that we as individuals have no sense of responsibility.

Take the BBC headline today "Obesity 'not indiduals fault'" gives the impression that we should not fight the problem as obesity is inevitable. That may not be the message of the article but the headline offers excuses. Similarly the report on the schoolrun "Schoolruns do not cause obesity" is very misleading. Walking for six minutes daily may not be sufficient to change children from being game-playing couch potatoes but the attitude behind the parents dropping the kids is the problem. So many parents drop children in cars because they fear they are not safe walking (despite no evidence of that). As a result children do not go out to play in our parks. 30 years ago public parks were full of children playing games like football and they were exercising and having fun. Today parks are empty apart from dog walkers while the children are safe sitting in front of the telly.

Even the report today I think gives the message that obesity is inevitable and not individual responsibility. This is London says

But modern life - with the easy availability of cheap unhealthy food and families relying on their cars - means it is almost impossible for many to avoid putting on weight.

Indeed, it is becoming inevitable for most because our biological instincts combined with our modern environment mean we are "destined" to pile on the pounds.

So while we have had significant lifestyle changes we are still making choices - wrong choices - as individuals. If I think back 30 years:

- Most people used cars sparingly and two car families were not the norm
- People walked to the shops and to schools
- People used bicycles for short journeys and for recreation
- People knew how to cook with fresh ingredients
- People ate smaller portions
- More people had physical work
- Chidren played outside in streets and parks and thereby exercised

Today think of what has changed:

- Most families have multiple cars (I'm guilty)
- Many people use cars for shopping or taking children to school (I'm guilty on the former but not the latter)
- Many people feel unsafe cycling and children are often forbidden to cycle far (not guilty)
- Many people do not use fresh ingredients and focus on ready meals or takeaway food (not guilty)
- Portions (especially of junk food) have exploded (don't think so)
- Most people have sedentary work (guilty)
- Parents feel safe if their children are playing indoors on a game console, computer or in front of the TV (not guilty)

Of course the Government has a role to play too. Other countries have invested far more in cyclepaths and footpaths - ours appear to be designed by people who never cycle - we can do the same. Schools should teach straightforward healthy cooking. The government should counter the sensational treatment of child crime cases by the media by pointing out that it is safe for children to go out.

Maybe I am a hypocrite writing this as somebody both overweight and with hypertension. However at least I see some responsibility to exercise and eat healthily.

Trackback address for this post:

authimage

Comments, Trackbacks: Hide subcomments

The_WalrusThe_Walrus [Member]
http://www.doctor-dark.co.uk
2007-10-17 @ 11:54

I've been losing weight ever since I stopped eating so much. Wierd, innit?

Wierd indeed...and I've been losing weight since starting an exercise programme again. Trouble is when ever I go on a business trip it goes to pieces...

FunkyFarmerFunkyFarmer [Member]
2007-10-17 @ 12:17

I'm a bit large as well but in my case it's a medical problem.

Every time I lift my arm with a burger in it, me mouth opens!

The government should set up a public enquiry I say. Into what, I hear you ask? Gawd knows but that don't matter

Oh well, try lighter burgers!

Bellydancer [Visitor]

2007-10-17 @ 19:39

You have written a lot of true things which is anything but hypocritical. It`s just true.

It`s not just the way we eat or not excercise, it`s a combination of everything. Personally, I still think that junk food is too readily available.

If you go to a kiosk or food van you may get soggy mayo sarnies, crisps and chocolate (kiosk) and chips, burgers, sausages and baked fish (in food vans). There are no healthy choices, not even for those who want them.

Yes, you are speaking of fast food whether of the traditional British or American variety. There is little in the way of healthy choices unless you buy fresh raw ingredients yourself.

Even supermarket salad bars are a disappointment due to the unappetizing use of mayonaisse in everything.

15 years ago when working in Munich there was an excellent delicatessen near my office. The salad bar was mainly shredded raw vegetables, but there were also tasty dressings and some things e.g. finely chopped ham, bacon bits, croutons, etc that could be added to give more taste but (at least in small quantities) not making it less healthy. Sadly the business moved to another area, but even the German supermarket salad bars e.g. Tengelmann were healthier than say Sainsburys here.

Oh and by the way,

If you feel strongly, write to some of our newspapers. A danger I see with blogging is that we attract people of similar views and moan at each other while the public at large goes on as usual.

I don't care what your favourite newspaper is but there is a reasonable contact list available at http://www.ukma.org.uk/your_role/newspapers.htm

While 3 of my grandparents are Scottish and there are some Scottish things I love, my experience there was that there were a lot of food problems between 1975-1985

O.

ranfuchsranfuchs pro
2007-10-17 @ 20:25

There is another factor that should not be ignored. Fresh vegs are normally the most expensive part of any meal. So it is much easier to cut on your tomato than on your pasta.

Why doesn't the govenment use junk food tax to support and Subsidise more healthy food?

I do not really agree. Surely fresh meat or fish is more expensive per kilo than fresh veg?

ranfuchsranfuchs pro
2007-10-18 @ 12:26

I agree if units of weight is the criteria, but we do not eat the same amounts of vegetables and meat, and therefore the comparison by weight may not be appropriate (which is the prime idea of the Atkins diet)

By the way, I do not talk about meet, fish etc, which is a different discussion, but on real junk food. For instance, at Tesco, for instance, you buy 2 pizzas for 4.00 This would normally be enough for at least 4 people. That is 50p per person. Pies are about the same. The worst grade fresh tomato, for instance, at the same shop is 64p each.

So what would a typical mother, who does not have much money to spend, and even less free time to prepare food would choose for her kids?

The way to obesity, is her easiest choice.

technomisttechnomist [Member]
2007-10-27 @ 19:37

The perception that vegetables are expensive can be changed by going to markets to buy them and avoiding Tescos, ASDA, Sainsbury's etc. where they are generally very over-priced.

Its not, of course possible for everyone, but where I live in Walthamstow we have a genuinely competitive market in fresh produce and places like Sainsbury's have found they can't match it. This is not just caused y market traders having lower overheads, other stores can beat them hands down. The porblem is the big supermarkets don't really compete with each other anymore. They operate by driving out local competition where they can and then just match what the other big chains are getting away with at a national level. I have recently been looking into this in some detail in some blogs and will be returning to it agin in the coming weeks:

http://archipelago-of-truth.blog.co.uk/2007/10/12/the_turkish_shop~3124370

ranfuchsranfuchs pro
2007-10-27 @ 21:07

This is very interesting. And what about internet grocery? Is there any good quality and reliable fresh food internet suppliers?

But this is a bit beside the point. If – as reported last week in the papers – the government considers obesity to be a problem of the magnitude of global warming, they have to do something about it. Otherwise, as long as affordable fresh groceries are hard to come by, obesity is here to stay.

I must admit the only food I have ever ordered on the internet was specialised Japanese ingredients I could not find in my home town. I know there are some suppliers of organic vegetables. I know people who order a weekly "vegetable box" e.g. from http://www.riverford.co.uk/

ranfuchsranfuchs pro
2007-11-04 @ 02:40

We have just ordered the vegtable box for the first time, we are going to try a few companies and compare. I will keep you updated

ranfuchsranfuchs pro
2007-11-04 @ 02:40

We have just ordered the vegtable box for the first time, we are going to try a few companies and compare. I will keep you updated

What you say rings true to some extent. I did not reply immediately but wanted to research it a bit.

I agree you can buy two pizzas at Tesco (not the worst) for £4.50 (judging by my visit to Basingstoke today). With small kids that would feed a family of four; though with teenage lads we would end up one one pizza each.

However you can cook a wholesome meal for £4.50 (even if it is restricted). My wife bought 500 g stewing steak earlier this week at Sainsburys (it sold at £4.10/kg so that was just over £2). Sainsburys' cheapest potatoes are 37p/kg and we would use half a kilo to go with the meat. If you cooked seasonal carrots (62p/kg) to serve with it you are at £3 for the main ingredients plus up to another pound more for herbs, spices, etc. However, I do not know many people who would take the 4 pieces of stewing steak and cook them like my wife does. She just seasons them, browns them and adds water. After 3 hours the meat is incredibly tender and braised in its stock. However most people aim for more expensive prime cuts of meat. My wife also has to plan ahead.

I agree with your point that it is very tempting for families to cook inexpensive junk food and simple to prepare. However I also maintain it is possible to cook healthy alternatives for the same price if you know how. Maybe this is a challenge for my food blog ;-)

ranfuchsranfuchs pro
2007-11-04 @ 02:44

I will be following your blog closely. As both me and my wife are working, it is not easy to find a good combination of health, cost and ease (speed) of preperation (naturally, it should also be suitable to kid's taste)

This is very thought-provoking as I am sure many people follow the line of thinking you describe. Shortly after you posted this I did a mini-survey of prices at my local supermarket. I have finally got round to posting about this http://foodfun.blog.co.uk/2007/12/20/is_the_way_to_obesity_the_economic_choic~3470483

hintzeyanghintzeyang pro
2007-10-17 @ 20:58

I was hearing the radio five live debate on this topic too this morning on my way to office. It is alarming to know in this country that some citizens actually recommends the government to subsidy for their gym as they thought the government is to be blamed partly for their fat...

I believe that the government has a role to correct major problems in society. However it is very sad if any bad behaviour is blamed on HMG unless there are mega health warnings.

Doubtless those of us who binge drink or slowly drink too much will have health problems that the NHS will pick up.

The Government should be involved in education on healthy eating and exercise but should not be blamed for fat due to poor individual lifestyle choices.

ranfuchsranfuchs pro
2007-10-27 @ 21:22

People also blame and sue McDonalds for their obesity. As much as I hate McDonalds, I still have not seen anyone pushing people into their restaurants, or any force feeding practices. On the other hand, some legal control to protect kids may be a good idea. I have two suggestions to control McDonalds (and the like) targeting children:

1. We should have age-rating for restaurants. That is, M rating will mean that children can’t go in without an adult. Actually they already have this M symbol everywhere, people are not aware what it really mean.
2. Just like with cigarettes, why don’t we force junk food restaurants to put ads like: This Food Kills
3. and completely unrelated thought. In nature the combination of red and yellow is a sign for danger: don’t eat me I am poisonous. Does it have anything to do McDonalds choice of colours?

There is an epidemic of childhood obesity in North America and I would be so bold to say that is another form of child abuse. Little exercise and poor eating habits. Dang shame.

ranfuchsranfuchs pro
2007-10-27 @ 21:09

So who is the abuser? The government or the parents?

Both abuse children. Some parents are unable to afford fresh fruit and veg and buy foods packed with high carbohydrates and then plunk their children in front of the teevee or video game console.

The government is starting to support teevee programs and school initiatives where the focus is on healthy eating and healthy lifestyle but does not channel enough money to people who are poor and unable to afford healthy, nutritious food.

That's a simplistic answer when the issue is highly complex.

ranfuchsranfuchs pro
2007-10-27 @ 21:09

So who is the abuser? The government or the parents?

technomisttechnomist [Member]
2007-10-27 @ 21:32

The government doesn't put a burger in my hand. I do.

They have some responsibility regarding school menus, sure, but they should be giving children good information about what a healthy meal is and encouraging them to take their bodies seriously, and teaching them about being responsible for themselves and the choices they make. Parents have to take the main lead however.

ranfuchsranfuchs pro
2007-10-28 @ 10:23

I agree that adults are responsible for themselves, but what about protecting children. Just look who the ads and who maketing is aimed for -- young kids. Shouldn't we at least protect our kids.

We do it with Alcohol, cigarettes, we are trying to do it with Porn. Why not do it with unhealthy food?

Leave a comment :

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.
Allowed XHTML tags: <!, p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, a, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small, img>
URLs, email, AIM and ICQs will be converted automatically.
Options:
 
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email & url)
Validation code:
Please enter the above code here:
For protection from spambots (case-sensitive).

Recent Posts

  1. In the taxi to Hyderabad airport
    by Oregano pro on 2008-07-03
  2. Office view in Hyderabad
    by Oregano pro on 2008-07-02
  3. New Airports
    by Oregano pro on 2008-07-01
  4. Pompey won!
    by Oregano pro on 2008-05-17
  5. US, oil, Bush, etc
    by Oregano pro on 2008-05-17
  6. Finlag
    by Oregano pro on 2008-04-30
  7. What is it about pubs?
    by Oregano pro on 2008-04-26
  8. T5 Shame
    by Oregano pro on 2008-04-09
  9. Highland Chieftan Inverness to London
    by Oregano pro on 2008-03-19
  10. Caledonian Sleeper London to Inverness
    by Oregano pro on 2008-03-18